Natural Antidepressant NEWS & VIEWS
edited by Syd Baumel
  Books by Syd Baumel
Dealing with Depression Naturally: Complementary and Alternative Therapies for Restoring Emotional Health

Buy at Amazon

Natural Antidepressants: Tried and True Remedies from Nature's Pharmacy

Buy at Amazon

Serotonin: How to Naturally Harness the Power Behind Prozac and Phen-Fen

Buy at Amazon

Articles | Record reviews

About Syd Baumel

Feedback | HOME

October, 2005 THIS JUST IN . . ..

Bright light for depression during pregnancy
A pilot study from Yale School of Medicine suggests bright light therapy has comparable benefits to antidepressant drugs in pregnant women.

Another sunny antidepressant
An Iranian research team validates the traditional reputation of the golden spice, saffron, as an antidepressant. In patients with mild to moderate depression, saffron performs significantly better than a placebo and as effectively as two major antidepressant drugs, imipramine and Prozac

Did St. John's Wort Strike Out - Again?
The much anticipated NIMH/NCCAM trial of St. John's wort fails to support the herb's efficacy for moderately severe major depression. But superdrug Zoloft flunks too. Critics say, don't jump to conclusions. 

A Fishy Remission
For the first time, a major medical journal publishes a remarkable case study of remission from severe, chronic, suicidal, treatment-resistant depression thanks to a high dose of EPA, one of the omega-3 fatty acids found in fish oil.

The Problem with Paxil 
It's been an open secret for years among users of Paxil (paroxetine), a popular treatment for depression and social anxiety disorder. Now the FDA has forced GlaxoSmithKline to stop pretending one of its bestselling drugs doesn't cause severe withdrawal symptoms in many would-be quitters.The drug company also faces legal action.

Kava Kava Alert
Kava - a popular euphoric and tension-relieving herb - may not be as safe as it first seemed. Recently, a rash of cases of liver disease and failure among German users has prompted the country's regulators to consider banning it. For chapter and verse on all of kava's effects, good and bad, click here.
The Way Up From Down
Psychiatrist Priscilla Slagle's 1992 guide to natural antidepressant therapies has been out of print for a few years. But not to worry. She's giving it away as a .pdf e-book on her website.
St. John's Wort's "Failed" Trial: A Closer Look
In April, 2001, the Journal of the American Medical Association published a large multicentre trial which was widely touted as proof that St. John's wort (SJW) doesn't really work for major depression. But not enough journalists read the fine print. For example, while only about 5% of the exceptionally chronically and severely depressed patients who received a placebo fully recovered, 15% who received SJW did. In letters to JAMA, at a Washington press briefing, and in a critique in Medical Herbalism, experts have taken issue with the study and its conclusions.
Cognitive therapy outsmarted by drugs
While most studies have found cognitive-behavioural therapies (CBTs) at least as effective as drugs, in this one cognitive therapy (the leading CBT) falls short. But then In clinical trials, the majority of depressed patients typically are female. In this trial the patients were all men. Could it be that women just respond better to psychotherapy?
Yoga for melancholia
In a randomised trial from the National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences in India, Kriya yoga - a technique that focuses on breathing - proves nearly as effective as ECT for patients hospitalised with severe depresssion.


 

CONTENTS
acupuncture | allergies | amino acids | the arts | Candida syndrome |the elements | fats and oils | flower remedies | the healing arts | herbs | homeopathy | hypoglycemia | the ion effect | massage | meditation | mercury amalgam dental fillings | minerals | nutrition | psychotherapy |resources | t'ai chi | toxic depressionyoga

AMINO ACIDS

SAM-e

  • All About SAM-e 

  • Although a little "HYP-e," Stop Depression Now is a great resource for information and motivation if you want to give SAM-e a TRY-e.
THE ELEMENTS
LightDarkHeatCold

Light

  • Not just for SAD

  • There's a lot more to bright light therapy than treating winter depression, according to a growing body of research. Other dark season symptoms may benefit, and any time of year so may any kind of depression.
THE HEALING ARTS

Music

HERBS
More big support for The Wort
In the largest and perhaps most rigorous multicentre trial to date, a standardised extract of St. John's wort (SJW) proves slightly more effective and dramatically more user-friendly than a full dosage of imipramine (the gold standard of antidepressant drugs) for 324 mildly to moderately depressed patients. The study comes hot on the heels of another large German trial in which the same SJW extract (Bayer's Ze 117) was decidedly more effective than imipramine's 1990s successor: Prozac. Again, SJW was far better tolerated than its pharmaceutical rival by this study's mildly to moderately depressed patients.
"Treating patients with mild to moderate depression can be a challenge. The mild nature of the disorder often precludes the treatments commonly used in severe depression, such as tricyclic antidepressants or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors....In these situations, an effective antidepressant with no (or comparatively few) side effects, which is acceptable to patients, would be an optimal treatment. Hypericum [SJW] seems to meet these criteria....

"In view of the mounting evidence of hypericum's comparable efficacy to other antidepressants and its safety record, hypericum should be considered for first line treatment in mild to moderate depression,especially in the primary care setting."

St. John's wort (SJW)

The crown prince of natural antidepressants (judging by its high public profile, at least), an ever-growing body of clinical trials suggest St. John's wort is about as effective as any drug - but far better tolerated - for mild to moderate depression. Indeed, despite assertions to the contrary by most experts, some of that research suggests SJW can be as effective as drugs for severe major depression too. At the other extreme, one review suggests SJW is every bit as effective as Prozac for the very mild or subclinical depressions or "blues" that many doctors are loathe to treat with drugs, as debilitating as they may be for their sufferers. 

With anecdotal reports suggesting SJW can relieve bipolar depression and studies indicating it's a good remedy for winter depression (SAD) too, it would seem SJW is an antidepressant for all seasons.

CAUTIONS

In 1999, evidence began appearing that SJW can speed up the body's breakdown of several drugs, including the blood thinner Coumadin (warfarin), the heart drug digoxin, oral contraceptives, cyclospor, theophylline, and fenprocoumon.

The biggest splash was made in the February 12, 2000, issue ofThe Lancet. The august medical journal contained a suite of papers on how hazardous these interactions can potentially be. In one report two patients would have rejected their heart transplants had their doctors not suspected the SJW they recently began taking. In another study, SJW dramatically speeded up the breakdown of a protease inhibitor named indinavir (Crixivan), commonly used to treat AIDS. Experts suspect SJW could have the same effect on other protease inhibitors, like AZT (Zidovudine).

Because of the uneliable quality control in the herb market, when adverse effects are reported for a herb, skeptics legitimately wonder if an atypical or adulterated formulation may have been used - or if it wasn't another herb or compound altogether. Unfortunately, this doesn't seem to be the case here. For example, in both of the heart transplant rejections reported in The Lancet, the patients were taking the gold standard SJW formulation: LI 160 (brand name Jarsin). And in another recent study, the chemical now regarded as the most therapeutically active ingredient in SJW - hyperforin - markedly stepped up the activity of a liver enzyme that helps break down indinavir and over 50% of all drugs.

At the same time, it seems SJW can increase the effect of anaesthetics.

Serotonin Syndrome

Vitex agnus castus
Hard New Evidence for Herbal PMS Remedy
In a large, well-controlled clinical trial, Vitex agnus castus proves more than twice as effective as a placebo for most symptoms of premenstrual syndrome - including depression.
 
 

 

HOMEOPATHY
Rejected by critics for appearing to "defy the laws of physics," homeopathy has nonetheless been supported by most of over 100 controlled clinical trials. Only a tiny portion of the published research suggests its subtle remedies can specifically relieve depression. But practitioners like the Ullmans (right) typically claim the right remedy for the right person can effect a deeper, long-lasting improvement - or cure - than most anything else.
     
  • The British Medical Journal publishes the latest and most objective of a series of controlled clinical trials to support this controversial modality.

Prozac-Free: Homeopathic Medicine for Depression, Anxiety, and Other Mental and Emotional Problems
Judyth Reichenberg-Ullman
and Robert Ullman
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca
MEDITATION

Mindfulness Cuts Stress, Boosts Mood
The experimental evidence that Buddhist mindfulness meditation can lighten people's loads continues to accumulate. In this randomised clinical trial, cancer patients taught the technique enjoyed a 65% reduction in depression, anxiety, and other symptoms of disturbed mood, among other benefits, after just seven weeks.
 

NUTRITION

High on omega-3s
A woman with a history of major depression undergoes a manic personality change soon after starting to take an omega-3 fatty acid supplement. Harvard psychiatrists comment that the long-chain omega-3s found in fish oil seem to cause mania only rarely, but the short-chain omega-3 found in linseed oil (alpha-linolenic acid) is another story.
Death from depression - dietary links?
Why are depressives so much more likely to die of heart disease? Psychiatrists argue omega-3 fatty acid deficiency is the "missing link."
But in another study, high blood levels of homocysteine - a recognised risk for heart disease - are found in 52% of severe depressives. The link here? Folic acid ( a B vitamin) defiiciency. It's highly prevalent in depressives, leading both to high homocysteine and to low neurotransmitter levels. (There may be other dietary links too. For example, depressives appear to consume more than their fair share of junk food - especially sweets, which raise insulin and triglyceride levels to the detriment of cardiovascular health.)
Winter depression: is vitamin D as important as light?
In a surprising clincial trial, a month of light therapy fails to improve winter depression (SAD), but a hefty dose of the sunshine vitamin does.
Prozac + vitamin beats Prozac alone
Depressives often have low levels of the B vitamin folic acid, and this tends to make them respond poorly to antidepressant drugs. Now, a large-scale study from the Medical Research Council in England finds that a supplement of folic acid gives depressives on Prozac a major edge. In women, the typical response rate of 61% on Prozac plus placebo soars to a whopping 94% on Prozac and a modest dose of the vitamin. But that's not all: the combo also reduces side effects over 50%.
 
PSYCHOTHERAPY

Problem solving as effective as Paxil - Sometimes
In a large randomised trial from Oxford University, just a few sessions of problem solving treatment (PST) proves very effective for major depression - as effective as a full dosage of Paxil or Luvox. But hot on its heels, in another large multicentre study from the USA, a touch of the innovative brief psychotherapy is less effective than Paxil. The patients in the study are all elderly and suffering from dysthymia (chronic mild depression) or minor depression. Most have chronic medical illnesses. While Paxil proves moderately more effective than a placebo and six brief, supportive office visits, six PST sessions (3.5 hours total) with briefly trained therapists rack up an unimpressive performance - except at one of the centres where the therapist excels in the technique. 
 
RESOURCES

Suicidal.com
The "downer" sitename belies the uplifting qualitiy of recovered depressive Melody Clark's valentine to websurfers struggling with severe depression and suicidal thoughts or impulses. Lots of warmly presented, thoughtful, and practical information on natural and conventional approaches both here and at Clark's sister websites, which include depressionfaq and suicidecrisiscenter.
 
TOXIC DEPRESSION

While it's widely accepted that toxic chemicals can promote cancer, birth defects, and other serious physical diseases, few people realise that the brain is the organ that usually gets intoxicated first. As E. L. Baker and associates of NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health) point out, "In the earliest form of chronic toxicity, mild mood disorders predominate as the patient's chief complaint."

"Electropollution"

YOGA

The asanas (exercise postures) and breathing exercises of hatha yoga have a reputation, backed up by some research, for improving practitioners' state of mind. They may help relieve clinical depression too.

  • Preliminary research in India suggests a type of yoga that features traditional breathing exercises can be effective even for the severest depression.

 
 
 

 

Books on Treating Depression Naturally:


 Beyond Prozac: Brain-Toxic Lifestyles, Natural Antidotes & New Generation Antidepressants 
Michael J. Norden
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Antidepressant Survival Program: How to Beat the Side Effects and Enhance the Benefits of Your Medication 
Robert J. Hedaya
(A holistic program - despite the title.)
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Prozac Backlash: Overcoming the Dangers of Prozac, Zoloft, Paxil, and Other Antidepressants with Safe, Effective Alternatives 
Joseph Glenmullen
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Depression-Free for Life: An All-Natural 5 Step Plan to Reclaim Your Zest for Living
Gabriel Cousens
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Natural Prozac : Learning to Release Your Body's Own Anti-Depressants
Joel Robertson, with Tom Monte 
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Stop Depression Now: SAM-e, the Breakthrough Supplement that Works as Well as Prescription Drugs in Half the Time . . . with No Side Effects
Richard Brown et al.
review by Syd Baumel
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Feeling Good:The New Mood Therapy
David D. Burns 
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Wisdom of Depression: A Guide to Understanding and Curing Depression Using Natural Medicine 
Jonathan G. Zuess
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Way Up from Down
Priscilla Slagle
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Fighting Depression
Harvey M. Ross
Amazon.com | Chapters.ca


Nature's Prozac: Natural Therapies and Techniques to Rid Yourself of Anxiety, Depression, Panic Attacks & Stress
Judith Sachs
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Potatoes Not Prozac: A Natural Seven-Step Dietary Plan to Control Your Cravings and Lose Weight, Recognize How Foods Affect the Way You Feel, and Stabilize the Level of Sugar in Your Blood
Kathleen DesMaisons
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Change Your Brain, Change Your Life: The Breakthrough Program for Conquering Anxiety, Depression, Obsessiveness, Anger, and Impulsiveness
Daniel G. Amen
Amazon.com|Chapters.ca


Natural Alternatives to Prozac 
Michael T. Murray
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Natural Healing for Anxiety and Depression
Harold Bloomfield and Deepak Chopra
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Anxiety and Depression: A Natural Approach
Shirley Trickett
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Depression Workbook: A Guide for Living With Depression and Manic Depression 
Mary Ellen Copeland
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Depression & Natural Medicine
Rita Elkins
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Prozac Alternative: Natural Relief from Depression With St. John's Wort, Kava, Ginkgo, 5-Htp, Homeopathy, and Other Alternative Therapies
Ran Knishinsky
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


St. John's Wort: Nature's Blues Buster
Hyla Cass
(SJW and beyond.)
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


The Zen Path Through Depression 
Philip Martin
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Curing Depression Naturally with Chinese Medicine 
Rosa A. Schnyer and Bob Flaws
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Sacred Sorrows: Embracing and Transforming Depression
John E. Nelson and Andrea Nelson (Editors)
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Natural Healing for Depression: Solutions from the World's Great Health Traditions and Practitioners
James Strohecker and Nancy Shaw Strohecker (Editors)
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Stress, Anxiety and Depression
Brian Fradet (Editor)
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Healing Depression: A Holistic Guide 
Catherine Carrigan
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca


Depression: Feeling Overwhelmed?
Hasnain Walji
Amazon.com
Chapters.ca